Our stay at Loggerhead Cay was nice and relaxing, but it got off to a rocky start when we arrived to find some cleanliness issues. Although there had been surface cleaning and restocking of the condo, we arrived to find stains in the refrigerator, grime on the floor around the refrigerator, drip marks on the kitchen cabinets, cobwebs on the light fixture, toothpaste splatter on the pictures in the master bath, and quite a thick layer of dust on several surfaces. Although a deeper cleaning probably can't happen every week between renters, it appeared to have not happened in quite some time and caused us to doubt and question the cleanliness of everything. This was not the welcome we expected or paid for, especially after driving for two days and looking forward to relaxing at the beach. We did call the after-hours number because it was 6pm on Saturday, and we left a message. However, no one ever returned our call about this, so we ended up doing some cleaning ourselves.
Once we cleaned, we were able to relax, and this condo really was comfortable and a decent size for our family of 6. The location with its view of the ocean was wonderful. The complex was quiet and not overly crowded. Both the pool and the beach were peaceful, and the water was mostly calm. There were so many shells! We also enjoyed the screened-in porch, the beach chairs and the beach cart.
Compared to other condos we have rented, we thought the pots & pans and cooking gear was limited, flimsy and in need of replacement. Also, as others have said, the accordion doors on the master bedroom with open slots and no lock did not provide much privacy or areas for people to have some space.
If you enjoy nature, we highly recommend Lovers Key State Park. It was a 40 minute drive from the condo, driving through Ft. Myers Beach. We kayaked to see manatees and dolphins, and at the beach found starfish and some really large live clams and mollusks, including an amazing conch shell. Pick up the New York style pizza from Citrola's on McGregor on your way back to the island … it was fantastic!
Overall we had a nice stay with only the (pretty big) disappointment at our arrival. Hopefully this can be addressed for future renters.