The positive: Color of the sea, beach house is clean, comfortable bed, The Kitchen restaurant quality, staff is friendly and always helpful, turtle point reef boat trip (snorkeling) and private boat trip were awesome, lots of vegetation and birds on the island, free gym access.
Negative: We changed beach house uppn arrival because the view was terrible (stone walls in front of the sea). Ants were in the room, other than that it was clean. Poor breakfast buffet, very few gluten-free options on the buffet, no fresh fruits, coconuts can only be bought at the beach bar. The Kitchen made gluten-free meals for us but we had to explain it to multiple waiters although we already mentioned via email that we require gluten-free diet. Swimming is only allowed at 3 small shallow swimming areas. Half of the island's coast is ugly. Snorkeling is only interesting on expensive boat trips. Spa is expensive. Tennis court was often blocked by the staff playing basket ball. Everything is super expensive, e.g. $8 for sparkling water, $350 for the compulsory new years dinner per person, $32 for a pizza. Plus 2 taxes on every price: +8% and +12%. For this kind of money we would expect more.